television

COLBERT IN IRAQ, STEWART FIGHTS AT HOME

POSTED BY Buckminster Schumacker III | SUNDAY JUNE 7 AT 11:57 PDT 
TV Show Title: 

The big news in basic cable this weekend was that Stephen Colbert, comedian and host of Comedy Central's "The Colbert Report" has arrived in Iraq for a week of taping the program from an actual war zone.  It's a bold move on Comedy Central's part and, depending on your definition of "war zone," potentially a very brave move on Colbert, himself.  But some could argue that Colbert still has a lot of work to do if he wants to rival his colleague, "The Daily Show" host Jon Stewart in the race to be dubbed a Real American Hero.

Loyal reader Ron Najor made such an argument in an impassioned email sent to Screen Junkies this weekend, and we liked it so much, we thought we'd publish it.  Unlike the majority of posts on SJ, this is a completely serious rant.  But don’t panic.  We embedded some funny clips.

 

WHY JON STEWART IS THE NEW EDWARD R. MURROW

By Ron Najor

A modern day Edward R. Murrow, Jon Stewart carves up and dispenses with any who would do wrong as he marches forward to a brave new world.  He has single-handedly brought the country’s focus to the root of the very problem that plagues our modern day news corporations.   With NBC being owned by General Electric and several NBC sister companies in bed with the financial sector, it blatantly and knowingly misled and misinformed the public.  I knew that; my friends and I talked about it.  But Jon Stewart exposed it for the farce it was.  And only through his comedic but bold interviews did we finally see someone in the national spotlight hold the media accountable for its huge part in all of this.

The following three clips feature the now famous showdown between Jon Stewart and Jim Cramer, a financial analyst and host of “Mad Money” on CNBC.  In many ways, this meeting mirrors similar events that took place when Edward R. Murrow faced Joseph McCarthy on “See It Now”. 

SEE THE COMPLETE UNEDITED 3 PART VERSION: 

March 12, 2009: Jim Cramer Unedited Interview Pt. 1




March 12, 2009: Jim Cramer Unedited Interview Pt. 2




March 12, 2009: Jim Cramer Unedited Interview Pt. 3

For those who may not know, Edward R. Murrow, beyond being a highly respected journalist in his day, was immortalized as the man who took down Joseph McCarthy.  McCarthy, a politician from Wisconsin, started the “Red Scare” and accused masses of Americans of being communist. Being called a communist back then was the equivalent of being called a terrorist today. Ruining countless lives, McCarthy's wrath engulfed anyone who opposed him and few did.  Until Edward R. Murrow called him out and brought to light to the nation the wrongs he had committed upon so many innocent Americans.  The News did its job and helped its people find truth in a chaotic time.

This clip shows Edward R. Murrow calling out Joseph McCarthy on his news broadcast “See It Now,” a show which in many ways resembled Stewart’s “The Daily Show,” but with clearly fewer laughs.

Stewart, a satirist/comedian, was hired by Comedy Central to make fun of the news when Craig Kilborn left “The Daily Show” in 1999.  I can’t imagine anyone thought he’d do such a good job of it. Jon Stewart is a fluke, really, which is the scary part of all this.  His job was to make fun of the media and current events, but was never thought of as a legitimate opportunity to expose our country’s failures and corruptions.  “The Daily Show” was engineered for a few laughs and I don’t think it was ever thought to bring about any type of social change or enlighten the public as it has done in the past several years.  You can be sure corporations will think twice before allowing someone like a Jon Stewart to break through and do the job of the news who have so neatly fit in the back pocket of the corporations that own them today.

So many of the journalists today are loyal to the corporations that hire them and pay their (often) exorbitant salaries. We the people are no longer told the truth, but rather a version that is in line with the corporations that own the news channels.  Now, I do realize there are good journalists out there, but corporate news people are not only in a conflict of interest but a conflict of ethics.  Do you do what is right when doing what is right bites the hand that feeds you and your family?  We have allowed our news to develop into a structure where it can no longer fully provide for the people.

It’s clear that corporate news has failed the American people.  Whether it is their misleading reporting on the financial sector that Jon Stewart exposed or the War in Iraq that turned out to be one colossal lie with no Weapons of Mass Destruction and no terrorist linked to the 9/11 disaster.  The corporate news was not only on board for both of these events but lead the charge.  Corporate news has done nothing to inform or challenge the powers at be because they themselves are the powers at be. 

I think we need a clear separation of corporations and news before it is too late.   Access to honest and fair reporting is something we all desperately need to make informed and proper decisions as Americans.  Without a [televised] news source that is acting on behalf of the people we are left to blindly make decisions that will not only impact us but future generations and the people around us on a global level.  We have a responsibility to the global community to get the best information to the people and try our best to make sure it is accurate and credible.  The present corporate news entities have proven to be none of these.


I say this all not with a sense of satisfaction but nervously wondering once Jon Stewart goes, whom will we turn to, to help impart information to us as citizens.  If corporate news has its way we will all sit blindly by as we are fed their version of “fair and balanced” journalism.

Good night America and good luck Jon Stewart!

-- RON NAJOR

As a bonus, here’s a clip of Jon Stewart famously taking down the hosts of “Crossfire” ENJOY:

Soon after Stewart’s appearance, “Crossfire” was cancelled.

 

 

 


  1. Says:
    Well done Ron. I rarely watch the Daily Show but loved watching Cramer and the Crossfire guys squirm. Stewart truly is an anomaly, and I wish there were more people like him around. I agree that we need a separation between corporations and news, but I fear that the general public are a good 30-50 years too late in realizing there is a massive conflict of interest there. Does anyone honestly think that corporations are going to relinquish the stronghold they possess over modern media and the news? There is a responsibility to get the news - and the truth - out there. Especially when, like you said, we need it to make decisions that will have an impact on a global level. In my opinion the reality here is that the old formula is failing (as you've just reported) so it's time to start a new one. That means a few things: At the very least, educate your loved ones or your community at a grass roots level about the lack of truth in news corporations, i.e. most news, and encourage them to do research for themselves. Next, think outside of the box, and create or look for new outlets for information and new ways to broadcast it without being easily corrupted. (who would've though the Daily Show would have turned into a place people turn to to get to the bottom of things? But alas, C.C. is corporate owned as well) Websites are a good place to start, but the real solution is yet to be discovered. There is an answer out there though, and that's exciting. Lastly, cherish people like Stewart while they are around and making a difference. Because it's possible that soon they won't be.
  2. Says:
    Great article! Loved the arrangement of clips to back up/add to the article. Ron did a fantastic job explaining what is really going on in news corporations today.
  3. Says:
    Ron, these clips are shocking! I had been told about this Cramer interview by a number of friends, but hadn't yet watched it. Cramer's hypocrisy is despicable. I recently read a book that might peak your interest: True Enough: Learning to Live in a Post-Fact Society by Farhad Manjoo Thank you for article. I will certainly forward it to friends.
  4. Says:
    Good article, Ron! Hope to see more writing and films and shows from you. We need voices like yours out there. More Jon Stewarts for my friends!
  5. Says:
    wow ron, you really hit it on the head man.
  6. Says:
    great stuff. there is nothing more entertaining and educational than the stewart/colbert combo
  7. Says:
    good show god show
  8. Says:
    Great article!
  9. Says:
    I don't normally watch Jon Stewart, but I really enjoyed watching and listening to him present his views. It was very eye opening and truly hit home and gave me so much to think about. Your article was well written and very informative. I really enjoyed being enlightened about the underlying "shananigans" that unfortunately are part of our American society. You did such an amazing job! Looking forward to reading more from you! :)
  10. Says:
    Funnier than the show!
  11. Says:
    I don't know about funnier than the show. Well written article. Stewart has managed to shake the comedian stigma and become kind of a legit journalist.
  12. Says:
    "We the people are no longer told the truth" I'm sorry but We the People have never been told the truth. Media's job has never been to tell the truth, it's been to sell product/advertising. Nothing more. If you think any one program has your best interest in mind then they've done their job, you've not done yours.
  13. Says:
    "We the people are no longer told the truth" "I'm sorry but We the People have never been told the truth." I disagree with this statement....watch Bill Moyer on PBS or KCRW's Left Right and Center. 60 Minutes has brought to light many very unpopular things from torture in Iraq to how tobacco really effects us. To say we have NEVER been told the truth is in itself false. To have such low expectations and to just surrender the desire for the News to be honest is something I am afraid I will not give up. I think this article makes a distinction between "Media" and "News" also. Media is going to lie to you but the "News" should be held more accountable and to a higher standard If we go in with this notion of "nothing will ever be better" than we will fail before we begin. I just see things differently but I respect your feelings on the situation.
  14. The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
    CAPTCHA

    If you don't want to figure out this word every time you comment, please either login or register for an account.