A Pickens County, South Carolina woman was arrested for not returning a VHS copy of Monster-in-Law she had rented nine years ago.

Kayla Michelle Finley was visiting the sheriff's office to deal with another matter when her encyclopedia-like knowledge of the J.Lo - Jane Fonda comedy aroused suspicion. The outstanding warrant for her arrest was then discovered and she was arrested. It remains unclear whether or not deputies conducted a strip search to turn up the tape.

She spent a night in prison and was released the following day on a $2,000 bond. The judge had considered the death penalty but softened its verdict when it was discovered she was kind enough to rewind. (WYFF-4)