This is a tough one. Frailty’s Adam Meiks only kills those that he or his father consider to be demons. Godsend’s Adam Duncan doesn’t exactly fall into this category, though he is possessed by the soul of an evil child. Adam Duncan is definitely the more devious of the two and he’s far more likely to get the drop on Adam Meiks. Unless his true nature can be seen. That being the case, it’s likely that Adam Meiks would methodically dispose of Adam Duncan.
Our Pick: Adam Meiks
I could easily see a scenario where the possessed Regan from The Exorcist and The Ring’s Samara grapple with neither coming up the victor. It’s only through self-sacrifice (or human interference) that this match would end. The only way this fight is ending is with the two demons tearing into one another, when they eventually both fall into Samara’s well before being swallowed up by a Hell portal.
Our Pick: Tie
These two are too similar to ever be able to get along. There can only be one murderous adopted child bludgeoning victims around these parts. Although I feel the advantage goes to Esther, she technically should be DQ’ed. She’s not a child at all, but rather an adult dwarf con woman who pretends to be a sweet child. In other words, she’s a ringer.
Our Pick: Rhoda Penmark By Disqualification